All GOTY games By votes ↓

• 18 / 21 Elden Ring
• 17 / 21 The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild
• 15 / 21 God of War (2018)
• 12 / 21 Hades
• 11 / 20 The Last of Us
• 10 / 22 Overwatch
• 9 / 19 Baldur's Gate 3
• 8 / 21 Dragon Age: Inquisition
• 8 / 17 The Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim
• 8 / 26 The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt
• 8 / 14 Uncharted 2: Among Thieves
• 7 / 16 Mass Effect 2
• 6 / 14 Grand Theft Auto IV
• 6 / 10 Half-Life 2
• 6 / 17 Portal 2
• 6 / 16 Red Dead Redemption
• 6 / 21 The Last of Us Part II
• 6 / 19 The Legend of Zelda: Tears of the Kingdom
• 5 / 15 BioShock
• 5 / 26 Bloodborne
• 5 / 21 Control
• 5 / 19 Journey
• 5 / 21 Outer Wilds
• 5 / 10 Resident Evil 4
• 5 / 15 Super Mario Galaxy
• 4 / 22 Deathloop
• 4 / 14 Fallout 3
• 4 / 12 Gears of War
• 4 / 12 Grand Theft Auto III
• 4 / 12 Halo: Combat Evolved
• 4 / 12 Metroid Prime
• 4 / 21 Resident Evil 2 (2019)
• 4 / 26 Super Mario Maker
• 4 / 12 The Legend of Zelda: Twilight Princess
• 4 / 19 The Walking Dead
• 3 / 19 Dishonored
• 3 / 20 Grand Theft Auto V
• 3 / 12 Grand Theft Auto: Vice City
• 3 / 21 Middle-earth: Shadow of Mordor
• 3 / 22 Psychonauts 2
• 3 / 21 Red Dead Redemption 2
• 3 / 21 Sekiro: Shadows Die Twice
• 3 / 8 The Sims
• 3 / 22 Uncharted 4: A Thief's End
• 2 / 19 Alan Wake II
• 2 / 14 Batman: Arkham Asylum
• 2 / 12 Battlefield 1942
• 2 / 21 Bayonetta 2
• 2 / 20 BioShock Infinite
• 2 / 15 Call of Duty 4: Modern Warfare
• 2 / 14 Call of Duty: Modern Warfare 2
• 2 / 5 Call of Duty
• 2 / 22 Chicory: A Colorful Tale
• 2 / 21 Dark Souls II
• 2 / 21 Destiny
• 2 / 8 Deus Ex
• 2 / 26 Fallout 4
• 2 / 19 Far Cry 3
• 2 / 21 God of War Ragnarök
• 2 / 10 God of War
• 2 / 21 Half-Life: Alyx
• 2 / 10 Halo 2
• 2 / 22 Inscryption
• 2 / 22 It Takes Two
• 2 / 14 LittleBigPlanet
• 2 / 26 Metal Gear Solid V: The Phantom Pain
• 2 / 15 Portal
• 2 / 5 Star Wars: Knights of the Old Republic
• 2 / 16 Super Mario Galaxy 2
• 2 / 26 Super Mario Odyssey
• 2 / 21 Tetris Effect
• 2 / 22 The Last Guardian
• 2 / 12 The Legend of Zelda: The Wind Waker
• 2 / 21 The Outer Worlds
• 2 / 8 Tony Hawk's Pro Skater 2
• 2 / 21 Untitled Goose Game
• 2 / 19 XCOM: Enemy Unknown
• 2 / 22 Returnal
• 2 / 22 Resident Evil Village
• 1 / 21 80 Days
• 1 / 16 Alan Wake
• 1 / 14 Borderlands
• 1 / 21 Celeste
• 1 / 19 Cocoon
• 1 / 22 Dark Souls III
• 1 / 14 Demon's Souls
• 1 / 8 Diablo II
• 1 / 22 Doom (2016)
• 1 / 10 Doom 3
• 1 / 19 Fez
• 1 / 12 Final Fantasy XII
• 1 / 21 Fortnite Battle Royale
• 1 / 22 Forza Horizon 5
• 1 / 21 Ghost of Tsushima
• 1 / 20 Gone Home
• 1 / 10 Grand Theft Auto: San Andreas
• 1 / 19 Guild Wars 2
• 1 / 10 Guitar Hero
• 1 / 15 Halo 3
• 1 / 26 Her Story
• 1 / 22 Halo Infinite
• 1 / 22 Hitman (2016)
• 1 / 12 Ico
• 1 / 22 Inside
• 1 / 14 Left 4 Dead
• 1 / 21 Mario Kart 8
• 1 / 19 Mass Effect 3
• 1 / 12 Max Payne
• 1 / 12 Metal Gear Solid 2: Sons of Liberty
• 1 / 14 Metal Gear Solid 4: Guns of the Patriots
• 1 / 22 Metroid Dread
• 1 / 17 Minecraft
• 1 / 12 Neverwinter Nights
• 1 / 21 Nier: Automata
• 1 / 12 Ōkami
• 1 / 22 Owlboy
• 1 / 20 Papers, Please
• 1 / 21 PlayerUnknown's Battlegrounds
• 1 / 5 Prince of Persia: The Sands of Time
• 1 / 26 Prune
• 1 / 10 Psychonauts
• 1 / 22 Ratchet & Clank: Rift Apart
• 1 / 19 Resident Evil 4 (2023)
• 1 / 26 Rocket League
• 1 / 12 Serious Sam: The First Encounter
• 1 / 10 Shadow of the Colossus
• 1 / 20 Super Mario 3D World
• 1 / 21 Tales from the Borderlands
• 1 / 12 The Elder Scrolls IV: Oblivion
• 1 / 20 The Legend of Zelda: A Link Between Worlds
• 1 / 17 The Legend of Zelda: Skyward Sword
• 1 / 22 The Witness
• 1 / 22 Titanfall 2
• 1 / 12 Tom Clancy's Ghost Recon Advanced Warfighter
• 1 / 17 Uncharted 3: Drake's Deception
• 1 / 22 Unpacking
• 1 / 21 What Remains of Edith Finch
• 1 / 21 Vampire Survivors
• 1 / 21 Wolfenstein: The New Order